Three Head-Scratching Years

Far be it for me to question anyone's position in hockey from where I sit, but I always found it strange that the Toronto Maple Leafs hired Bred Treliving to be their general manager three years ago. That's not to say that Treliving wasn't able to do the job, but it's hard to ignore the immense pressure that comes with sitting in the big chair in a city that demands a winner. Being that 1967 is a lifetime ago and the Leafs moving away from a playoff spot has to come with consequences, and Toronto brass made the move today to correct the path the team is on by firing GM Brad Treliving.

The idea of a playoff spot is all but lost at this point in this season, but it's some of the asset mismanagment that likely called for a change in the management structure for the Maple Leafs. After all, the "trade" to move Mitch Marner for Nicolas Roy was one of the worst in the history of the Maple Leafs while his deal to trade prized prospect Fraser Minten and a first-round pick to Boston for Brandon Carlo is hard to even rationalize. Add in baffling free agent signings like John Klingberg, Ryan Reaves, and David Kampf while not finding elite goaltending, and the writing started to appear on the wall.

Toronto won't have a first- or a second-round selection this season at the NHL Draft, so finding some immediate help will have come via trade or free agency. The team will need to make decisions on Calle Jarnkrok, Matias Maccelli, and Nick Robertson, but it's hard to see either of Maccelli or Robertson sticking with Toronto if another team appears interested. Robertson has asked for a trade out of Toronto for the past two seasons before finding a roster spot this season, so we'll have to see if he'll return on a new deal next season.

If that mismanagement of depth players isn't enough, making the decision to fire Sheldon Keefe while hiring the defensively-minded Craig Berube is also a head-scratcher. Keefe recognized that the defence and goaltending was, at best, in the middle of the pack. To counter this, he pushed the offensive side of the play as the Leafs scored a lot during the regular season. That wasn't a great strategy for the Leafs in the playoffs where the defensive play gets ratcheted up a few notches, but Keefe was playing the hand he was dealt.

Treliving was questioned for firing Keefe who was 212-97-40 over parts of five campaigns, but his playoff record shows that success was fleeting as he recorded a 16-21 record in the postseason including a 1-5 series mark. At the time, Treliving stated, "Sheldon is an excellent coach and a great man. However, we determined a new voice is needed to help the team push through to reach our ultimate goal."

Craig Berube was hired by Treliving following his brief success in St. Louis, the Leafs finally won just their second playoff series in more than 20 years under Berube's watch, but the Leafs dropped from 54 wins to 52 wins in 2025 before winning just 31 games to this point this season. If losing Mitch Marner had that much of an effect on the Leafs, this squad under Berube is more than just a few tweaks and minor moves away from being a Stanley Cup contender again.

In three consecutive seasons under Treliving, the number of wins and points fell. For the first time in ten seasons, the Maple Leafs are poised to miss the playoffs. For the first time since 2016, it appears there's a good chance that the Leafs won't have a 30-goal scorer on their roster. Some of that can be attributed to coaching, but a lot of it has to do with the roster that was assembled this season. The Leafs weren't good enough, weren't deep enough, and didn't get the contributions they needed with the personnel they currently have.

As was discussed in yesterday's article about the Golden Knights, accountability for the roster's successes or failures ultimately falls on the general manager. Based on the significant drop-off this season and the slight decline last season, changes had to be expected in Toronto. The first domino fell today with the dismissal of Brad Treliving as the Maple Leafs will look for a new candidate to lead them out of this mess and into a better, more successful era.

I can't deny that Toronto amplifies it by a million times, but hockey is still a results-driven business where winning matters. Brad Treliving is the latest evidence of that reality after being dismissed today.

Until next time, keep your sticks on the ice!